Wednesday, March 7, 2007

Art and Politics, Part 2

An Our Word Roundtable

Yesterday we introduced a four-part roundtable discussion of politics in the arts. (See the beginning of yesterday's post for the quote that started it all.) Part two continues the discussion. Remember, we're not necessarily experts - just opinionated.


Judith: Let’s talk some more about the inspiration for art. Camille Paglia had a very interesting point in a speech she gave at Colorado College last month – that people need to return to religious roots in order to produce art that is truly inspired. And this from a self-avowed atheist! Granted, someone can have deeply-held political beliefs and the talent to display them artistically, but anything – art or politics – means little if it doesn’t have something deeper than humanism or materialism as the outcome.

Mitchell: As far as I’m concerned, that’s the problem with this so-called “political art” that we’ve been talking about – all that’s really backing it is a political vision. There’s no artistic vision involved. It’s like we keep saying – they’re just preaching to the audience. Their first priority is a political one.

Judith: Remember last year when the Minnesota Opera did The Elephant Man? You mentioned it at the time.

Mitchell: They had this stuff about hosting a forum to discuss the disabled in America, something like that. Again, I think they were using the opera primarily to transmit a political agenda. And again, let’s see if fifty years from now, or even twenty, if The Elephant Man is a part of the standard opera repertoire.

Drew: But your point is that music has always been political, just not as overtly as it is now?

Mitchell: Yeah, there’s always been a political element to music. Mozart wrote The Magic Flute about Freemasonry. Beethoven’s Fidelio had this theme of freedom, the resilience of freedom and how people will always fight against injustice, and that struck a cord in the 30s and 40s when you had these dictatorships in Europe. It was kind of adopted as a theme by people fighting against totalitarianism.

Judith: But the key to these pieces is that the politics was never allowed to overshadow the art. Fidelio contains universal truths, and they’re going to be relevant no matter when it’s performed. But most people are going to appreciate it for the music, for how it sounds.

Drew: You could argue that The Magic Flute is the most heavy-handed of them all, with all that Masonic symbolism they have all over the stage.

Mitchell: And I have to admit that The Magic Flute’s probably my least favorite Mozart opera. You listen to the opera quiz on Saturday afternoons, that’s always the one opera most of them are saying they could go without for awhile.

Drew: But as long as we’re hanging around Germany, we probably ought to talk about Wagner. What about him?

Judith: The Israelis certainly consider his music to be political.

Drew: Yeah, they still don’t allow it to be played in public, although that’s been kind of flaunted in the last few years. I think, what’s his name from Chicago, Daniel Barenboim, performed Wagner in a concert there a few years ago. But you’re right, officially I think it’s still taboo. And there’s certainly no question that Wagner was political, and his politics are pretty odious. But some of this comes from what you read into an artist’s work. He’s bound to show some of himself in his work – he wouldn’t be an artist if he didn’t. And the Nazis certainly adopted him as their Kapellmeister. But here’s my point, and I’ve made this in the past, you can listen to Wagner purely for the music, the shear artistry of the man, and not be overwhelmed by whatever message he might be pushing.

Mitchell: Of course, you’re a big fan of Wagner, as I am.

Drew: Very big. Sure, he’s an acquired taste. You know, Mark Twain said that Wagner’s not as bad as he sounds. And I don’t think that was meant as an endorsement of the man personally, from everything I've read he was a miserable human being, but he wrote some of the loveliest pieces in all of classical music. You shut yourself off from a lot of beauty when you clamp your hands over your ears every time you hear the name of Wagner. And yet I don't blame the Israelis for their attitude.

Judith: The point again is that his music lives outside of the context in which it was written. It’s timeless.

Drew: I wrote this piece about Leni Reifenstahl, the German documentarian, last year. Even though we’re talking about music here, you can’t really talk about Wagner and the Nazis without getting into her. And there are those who see her films as nothing but Nazi propaganda. But if you look at them, they’re captivating, they tell an incredible story. And her techniques were legendary, the kinds of things that she pioneered. You can see her influence in filmmaking all over the place, movies like Star Wars. Again, there’s that timelessness that allows it to continue to be relevant. Maybe her movies were propaganda, although she would have argued that. But they were art as well, and she wasn’t going to make some shrill piece for Hitler that was nothing but clips of him screaming into the microphones and didn’t have any artistic value at all. Maybe people would have watched it back then, because they wouldn’t have had any choice, but we wouldn’t still be talking about it today.

Mitchell: I’m really reluctant to get into The Grapes of Wrath, the Minnesota Opera piece Alex Ross mentions, because we haven’t seen it.

Judith: Didn’t want to see it. Steinbeck’s too preachy in his work. I never cared for his novels when I had to read them in school.

Mitchell: I agree. I think the best thing he probably ever wrote was Travels With Charlie. And I still don’t think there’s any reason to be commissioning a piece like that when there’s so much good stuff out there that’s underperformed. But although people are talking about it like it’s a piece of Americana –

Drew: It is a classic, you have to admit that.

Mitchell: Sure, but there are a lot of classics I don't care for, like The Great Gatsby. Judie’s right, Steinbeck's got a leftist message that must be very attractive to the arts crowd. Would they have been willing to stage an opera based on one of John Dos Passos’ novels?

Judith: Of course not. Once Dos Passos turned to the right, they ostracized him. That’s why he never won a Nobel.

Drew: But that’s something that Ross is talking about, or maybe it was another critic, but Grapes is full of American music, telling the American story. Capturing the sounds of America, that kind of thing.

Mitchell: Which makes me think that it’s more properly musical theater than opera. But that’s for another time.

Drew: But I think the point is that it appears less threatening that way, and it makes the message more agreeable to people because they can appreciate that it sounds good.

Mitchell: You might have a point there. We’ll just have to wait and see if it catches on, if we still see it being performed 20 years from now. But you don’t deny that it’s got a liberal message.

Drew: No, of course not. It’s one man's opinion of the American story. And I think you’re right, how much of a factor did that play in its selection as a commissioned piece by the Minnesota Opera?

Mitchell: When you’ve got underperformed pieces like Menotti’s The Consul that aren’t performed as much any more.

Judith: I was wondering when you’d bring up Menotti. [Laughter]

Drew: At least from a topical standpoint, The Consul is as relevant as anything that’s out there today.

Judith: As long as you’ve got dictators and totalitarianism, you’re always going to be able to tell a story like that.

Mitchell: And that’s what makes it timeless.

Judith: Again, but that’s why it’s art and not just a political message. Because it can be performed without seeming to be a museum piece. Maybe the music’s dated, although I didn’t think so the last time I heard it, but as far as the story goes it’s as political as anything Verdi or Rossini would have written, and just as timeless.


Tomorrow: part three.


  1. A few thoughts:

    The Left's playbook on anyone who does not support them is to trash the person, regardless. Much of the Left's trashing of Ann Coulter has been based on the Alinsky strategy (see Barbara Olson's book Hell to Pay for information on it). The conservatives don't like her wording used in this instance, and I don't accept it. But the trashing is a different story.

    As for the inspiration of art, I agree. In the past, art was influenced by the church. Today, it is not. Albert Mohler of the Southern Baptist Theological Seminary once referred to today's art as the "high church of art" because they believe they are their own deities, and believe art can replace God.

    The trend in "modern worship" in church is probably an easy example of the comments. In the past, music of the world was influenced by music of the church. Now, music of the church is influenced by music of the world (modern rock, hip-hop, heavy metal, et al). It's not "solely for the glory of God," as Bach once wrote.

    "Political art" reared its ugly head, as I reflect, in even today's musicals. I attended a performance Friday of Mamma Mia!, a musical based on the tunes of Swedish supergroup Abba, which the writers did not even publish a libretto of the story in the regular program, and only some ambiguous comments about the plot were in the $10 souvenir book.

    The musical's plot involves a woman on an island in Greece, on the day before her wedding, and her mother, who is unmarried. The daughter wants to know who is her father, and there are three possible candidates, and all three are brought to the island.

    When trying to find out who is the father (without a paternity test -- imagine the horror of the Anna Nicole Smith situation!), she cannot identify who. One of the alleged father candidates does not announced until the end of the musical he is a deviant with a psychiatric disorder (in a relationship with another man). While the girl cancels the wedding at the last minute, the mother marries one of the other two men instead after the daughter says no to the marriage.

    I thought Dr. Laura Schlessinger was needed after the bad messages the musical produces.

    As for the dictatorships and Fidelio, you are correct about The Consul. The Consul was written shortly after World War II, and it felt to me in the performance I saw four years ago the plot was set in Nazi Germany.

    I get so angry at times I often say I want to take my own life, like Magda Sorel, and I usually say it with laughter.

    It came to the point at the mechanic's shop last October when I was stranded and couldn't make a half-marathon I was to have run that morning. I was penalised with a fine, lost everything I paid to enter the event, and lost training time for the upcoming marathon I was to run a few months later. I was so angry I said I wanted to take my own life, like Magda Sorel. Of course, most people don't understand the whole story about Magda's suicide scene and how it affects me.

    The Left believes that this nation should surrender to terrorists such as Al Qaeda, surrender to groups who support Psychiatric Disorders as normal, and bash Christians. Look at the cross being removed from the chapel at the College of William & Mary. Crosses are being removed from churches across this country as part of a new movement known as the "Emergent Church" movement, and the cross removal is part of the philosophy of not offending non-Christians at churches, and the movement is led by churches such as Willow Creek (Illinois), Saddleback (California), and Lakewood (Houston). These churches are also at the forefront of replacing the sacred music with the secular in churches, turning choirs into backup singers for pop/rock artists, and using teen dancers who jiggle to hip-hop as replacements for the choir.

    Liberal viewpoints in theatres -- movie and live -- are what create problems with finances and draws. Look at the draw of those which promote a liberal, secularist humanistic viewpoint. Look at the number of people who listen to Rush Limbaugh against those who listen to Air America. Look at Bill O'Reilly's popularity and understanding of the Culture War. Which one gets more listeners usually? Where I live in the suburbs, when a radio chain bought the local stations, he dropped news and Rush Limbaugh, replacing it with bad rock music of the 1970's. While complaints are up, the owners refuse to listen to angry locals.

    Note the films now being directed by Michael Landon, Jr.

    If this liberalism keeps continuing to get worse, the Oscars will lose their prestige and their Month of Money status. ABC needs the Academy Awards to be such because it is their only Month of Money event. NBC gets alternating Month of Money events (Super Bowl every third year, Olympics every fourth year). CBS has an annual Month of Money event (Grammy Awards, bad music was the big winners, as liberal anti-Americans won the big awards), and Fox has an annual Money of Money event (the Daytona 500, which they have until 2014, moved to prime-time finishes this year, where Happy and his Flying Dutchmen of Shell beat Mark Martin and the US Army in the last feet of the 505th mile of the 500-mile race).

  2. Excellent comments allaround, Bobby. In the combox below, we discussed the question as to whether or not politics can be totally removed from art, and I'm not sure it can - it would require removing politics from an individual, and I don't know whether or not that can be possible. However, it can certainly be removed from overt sensory expression.

    Considering the detrimental impact that overt, idological political art has (in terms not only of alienating people from that particular work of art, but also from the desire to become more actively involved in art, whether as a consumer, artist, or patron), one wonders if the left really has the best interests of art at hand, or if they are purely concerned with art solely as a means of political expression, something no more than a utilitarian vehicle.


  3. Dog Art Hi, if your a dog lover you will want to see this dog art.

  4. This is a great Blog! Pardon if I landed on the wrong blog.
    As a newbie I just can’t help sharing the following
    url with you. It made al the difference to my financial
    Situation. For only $7.00 you get your own
    ATM Machine. Just follow the link below!

  5. Domin8 MySpace with unique myspace music. Check out


Remember: Think Before Commenting.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...